Redo for Mastery. The story lacks flow. The elements and content are too difficult for readers to understand.
Approaching Mastery. The author has created a story with the necessary elements, but could improve the design and layout. The design is either overwhelming or lacks depth.
Mastery. The author has created an engaging story that captures attention and the design and layout show thought and care. Only 1 or 2 of the design elements may detract from the content or are unnecessary.
Above Mastery. The author has created an engaging story. The design and layout show good use of colors, space, effects, sound, animation, and/or transitions. These elements do not detract from the content.